When Opportunity Knocks . . . Be Careful!
When Opportunity Knocks… Be Careful!

Having a new book released is exciting. I appreciate my readers, friends, family, local bookstores, and fellow authors who generously give their time to help promote my books. Some invite me to be a guest on their podcasts or write a guest post for their blogs. Word of mouth and social media reviews are invaluable to authors who publish with small presses or independently.
But then there are these emails.
I receive plenty from organizations, groups, and supposed “fans” telling me how much attention my books deserve. They include wonderful synopses of my stories, flattering descriptions of my colorful characters, and examples of their humorous and thrilling antics. Some suggest ways I can sell thousands of copies. Others want to interview me on their radio programs, while a few promise to turn my books into movies. Yea! I’m thrilled—not!
Here are a few red-flag emails I received.
Small Red Flags
The public radio interview.
A legitimate public radio station wanted to interview me for its program. I visited its website, listened to several broadcasts, and was impressed. They wanted a $100 donation. That seemed reasonable enough. I told them I’d consider it if I could send a money order. They assured me their payment system was secure. I insisted on paying by money order. They assured me again that their system was secure and easy to use. I said no, thank you.
The next day, they emailed to ask if I had changed my mind. I deleted that one, too. The following morning, another email arrived. Delete. This went on for four days before they finally gave up.
The Goodreads book group
A Goodreads book group contacted me, offering to read my book and provide glowing reviews. They sent me four pages of guidelines and information. The final page revealed their fee: anywhere from $200 to $1,000. My response? “Thanks, but no thanks.”
I call these small red-flag inquiries. They might be legitimate business offers, but that doesn’t mean they’re right for me.
Big Red Flags
The Hollywood agent. A Hollywood agent wanted to turn my book into a movie. Imagine that! How exciting! Then I read the fine print. He wanted $15,000 and the rights to my story. Really?! That was a very big red flag waving right in front of me.
Terry Gross of NPR. Someone claiming to be Terry Gross wanted to interview me on Fresh Air. I used to listen to the program all the time. I loved it! It took me about two seconds to discover the offer was bogus. Two seconds. That’s all.
I’m grateful to my dad for passing along his suspicious nature. And I’m even more grateful that I married a lawyer.
When it comes to book promotion, I welcome opportunities, appreciate genuine support, and celebrate the people who help spread the word about my books.
But if an offer sounds too good to be true—or comes with a hefty price tag and a suspicious request for money or rights to my work—I’ll do my homework first.
After all, I write fiction. I don’t need someone else making up stories about a book deal!
Kathleen Kaska writes the award-winning Sydney Lockhart Mystery Series set in the 1950s and the Kate Caraway Animal-Rights Mystery Series. She also writes mystery trivia, including The Sherlock Holmes Quiz Book. Her Holmes short story, “The Adventure at Old Basingstoke,” appears in Sherlock Holmes of Baking Street. She founded The Dogs in the Nighttime, a scion of The Baker Street Irregulars.




It’s tiresome how many of these bogus offers we receive. One can understand how someone can get fooled. The information about the book(s) is really comprehensive. But unless the email references someone I know (referred by Kathleen Kaska) and I can check with that person, I no longer even read the rest of the email. Straight to junk.
References from authors you know and trust are the safe way to go.
What Judy said! And im so grateful you’re suspicious by nature!!!! Happy release. Iwelcome you on my blog any time, Kathleen. No charge!
Thanks, Donnell, you’ve always been a great and generous host.
These emails stared a few months ago. At first, it was one or two a day. I’m now clicking Delete on at least two dozen a day! Frankly, it’s another reason to hate AI.
The other day, I created a page on my website for my upcoming next release. The book isn’t available as an ARC anywhere yet. My critique partner just got the ms. to read yesterday. There’s no cover yet. But I’m already getting inundated with AI emails telling me how wonderful the book is and how they can help me find a broader audience!
Maybe AI will cure cancer one day soon or find a way to end world hunger, but for now, they seem more interested in trying to scam authors.
I feel bad for first-time authors. It’s so easy to fall for a scam when it sounds so flattering.
I’ve been watching other threads where people ask “Is this real?” They are so hoping the pitch in question is genuine, but it never is. My biggest fear as I constantly hit delete is missing a real invitation.
Great post, Kathleen. I read somewhere that authors are easy targets because, “They crave flattery.” I disagree. I think the bots are wasting their time with authors, because authors are great thinkers, not easily fooled.
I just read J.A. Jance’s blog for today – she was talking about this very topic as well. I get some, of course, as well. I did copy what I thought was surely a suspicious email and sent it to the magazine via an email from their website and they wrote back to say “Yes, that was from us” . A few grains of wheat in an awful lot of chaff.
I’m glad you checked.
How sad we are all getting bombarded with these AI-created junk offers dangling like diamonds, fake diamonds. Then I get angry thinking about writers so full of hope and dreams…. I am not angry at AI, but the people greedy, heartless who are behind this.